All notes

Psychology

Anchoring, and why the first number sticks

1 min readSample

Personal reading notes, not clinical or professional advice.

Anchoring is one of the better-known findings from Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman's work on judgement under uncertainty. The idea is simple: when people estimate a number, an earlier figure pulls the estimate towards it, even when that figure has nothing to do with the question.

What the research describes

In the classic demonstrations, people were shown an arbitrary number and then asked to estimate something unrelated. Those who saw a higher number tended to give higher estimates. Later studies found similar effects in pricing, negotiation and even expert judgement, although the size of the effect varies a lot between studies.

Why it seems to happen

Two explanations come up most often:

  • Insufficient adjustment: we start from the anchor and move away from it, but stop too early.
  • Selective accessibility: the anchor makes information consistent with it easier to bring to mind.

What I am taking from it

  • Write down my own estimate before looking at anyone else's.
  • Treat the first number in a conversation as information about the person who said it, not about the answer.
  • Ask what I would think if the anchor had been half or double.

None of this makes me immune. It just gives me a moment to notice the pull.